The woodstove that J. and I sat in front of on cold nights, the fire the only light in the room.
Yesterday was a good day up until the point where I checked the mail and noticed that a letter had been returned to me. There's a long story behind the writing of this letter, but for now, I'll just say that seeing it tucked in amongst my other mail only enhanced the bad feeling since the night the emotional tidal wave washed over me.
I'm using the words "tidal wave" metaphorically, because it wasn't that at all. I was not at the shore but sitting right here at my desk, when suddenly, a wave of memory crashed over me and pulled me completely under. I can't swim, so I know what almost drowning feels like. And this felt very much like that. Only it wasn't water threatening to drown me but the memory of a man I'd known long ago and that I'd totally lost touch with.
We met 21 years ago through an online chat room that was operated by Yahoo. Many people will remember the days of the Yahoo chat rooms. They were fun until they weren't, until the "rooms," as we called them, became overrun with chat bots that were there just to sell something that was, more often than not, pornographic in nature. With some discipline and self-control, chat rooms were a good venue for meeting new people, as long as one approached each potential new "friend" with caution. That's how I met J. And, as those who are familiar with chat rooms could attest, we instantly clicked. He sounded nice and not pushy like so many. We chatted awhile the first time and then again a few times until I decided to invite him to my place. From even just the few words he sent me, I already had a pretty good idea of what kind of person he was. His authenticity came through in his words, so that finally meeting him felt almost like deja vu.
At the time, I lived in a lovely little area in southern Maine called Lyman, a woodsy hilly territory dotted with small ponds and webbed by many small streams and brooks. I lived in a mobile home on top of a slope that looked down over a private dirt road, part of which I owned. Of my 5.2 acres, about 1/2 of an acre was occupied by the trailer, a workshop and a parking area. And at the bottom of the slope on the north side, a large 2-bay garage took up about another 1/8th of an acre. The rest was solid woodland on all sides, through which I'd forged paths and where I took many lovely solitary walks through the 13 years I was there.
Needless to say, J. fell in love with it the minute he saw it. A lover of solitude like I was, the place fit him and he fit it. We went on to have lots of very good times there during which we listened to music, danced, had private BBQ's, took walks in the woods, and sat in front of the wood stove with no other lights on other than the fire burning in the grate. If we'd done nothing else, it would have been enough. And it remains the strongest image of that time that I spent with J., along with the memory of the night we sat outside near the fire pit listening to owls hooting and the fire crackling.
In reality, J. was in Maine only temporarily. He was in the U.S. Navy, stationed at the Brunswick Naval Air Station and had a small apartment not far from the base, where I visited him a few times during the years he was here. Now that I look back on it, it wasn't a conventional relationship at all. I had no illusions about his feelings for me. I was 54 and he was 42, and I knew that the time we spent together was just that. He needed someone and something to fill his time in Maine, and I was willing to be that someone. I accepted him for what he was and for what he could give me, and nothing more. I asked few if any questions and accepted his few answers at face value.
I did question whether or not I was short-changing myself for not making the attempt to learn more about him and to demand more from him than just what he was willing to give. But I instinctively knew that it would never go anywhere, that what was happening in Maine would never be continued anywhere else. Besides, it felt so right and we got along so well that I really couldn't ask for more. Conversely, I realized that there was an almost mystical force at work behind his having come into my life. J. was so unlike anyone I'd ever known, first and foremost because he wasn't "from here." He'd grown up in the upper Midwest as part of a large family before being stationed in various foreign places by the Navy. That had given him a much broader view of the world than I could ever possibly have, not ever having traveled much myself.
I'd had a very unconventional and troubled childhood, particularly after I turned 13. I'd gained weight during puberty and never lost it. High school was hell, and it was only after that I decided that, if I was ever going to have a life, it would only be possible if I lost some weight. I'd been body-shamed often during those years by people I'd come to love and trust, and those are deep emotional wounds that never completely heal. So watching this handsome and virile young man come into my life was an incongruity considering the cloistered life I'd led as a teenager who never felt she deserved much. In a very real sense, J. was to fill needs that had never been filled back then, and he did just that. As crude as it may sound, he was very malleable and open to anything, including playing a role in the large fantasy I'd constructed with him as its catalyst.
The first night he spent in my woodsy place, I watched him walk out to his truck to get a few things and I stood at the door thinking, "Now what are you going to do? You're 12 years older than he is. You have NO idea what to do or how to be around someone like him." And then I did something that was totally out of character for me: I threw all caution to the wind and just went with it. I decided to just be myself. So far, he hadn't found any reason to leave, so that was a good sign.
We were to spend many more such nights and weekends. About a year or so later, he was dispatched to Bahrain for a month in the summer of 2005. When he got back, we simply returned to our old playbook of having drinks in front of the fire and listening to music all night into the wee hours. I'd cook for him, and nothing I did ever displeased him. In a very real sense, he was almost too good to be true, and I wondered what I'd done to deserve such a gift at this stage in my life.
In late fall 2005, he gave up his apartment in Brunswick and stayed with me one last week. The day he left, I knew there was a very good chance that I'd never see or hear from him again. It was a sad moment, but an inevitable one. I hated to see him go, as I'd gotten very attached to him, and I knew that I'd fallen in love with him. Watching him drive away down my long hilly driveway in his Silverado that day was one of the saddest moments of my life. I felt very empty for a long time after that, and I never did quite manage to fill the void he'd left behind.
It was quite some time before I heard from him again, and then we started emailing again. He said he was thinking of coming back to Maine for a vacation, as he missed me and my woodsy place. In the fall of 2007, I drove to Manchester Airport in New Hampshire to pick him up. He stayed a week, and dropping him back off at the airport was another sad time for me. After that, it would be years before I would hear from him again. I lost all contact with him, and in January of 2012, I sold my trailer and moved to the small village of Springvale, where I spent less than a year before moving back to Lyman to a new apartment over a garage that overlooked Wadleigh Pond. I was to spend three glorious years there before moving to Saco, Maine in November 2015, where I still live to this day.
Again, I don't recall much of the next few years other than I again hadn't heard from J. in quite some time, so naturally I wondered where he was and how he was doing. I suspected he'd gone back to the life he had never spoken much about, so I did the only thing I could do, and that was to send him cards on his birthday and then a card at Christmas. I'd always include my phone number, in the event his life had changed again and he felt like calling an old friend. The cards never came back, so he must have gotten them or the post office just discarded them as undelivered.
I'd come to relegate all memory of him to the past, when one day he did call. I was surprised but very happy to hear from him, hear his deep voice on the phone that I hadn't heard in so long. We had some good conversations, a few laughs, and we agreed to keep in touch. That went on until some time in 2020 when, at one point, something he said bothered me, and I made the decision to stop talking to him. He'd said some unreasonable things to me in the past, and I'd hoped that was behind us now. But for some reason, I thought the best thing would be to just not accept his calls anymore. So I blocked his number and went on with my life, believing I'd done the right thing. I'm sure others would agree that it was the right thing, in light of the fact that HE had been unreachable, too, for so long. But in retrospect I did agonize over why I hadn't taken him up on the things he'd said and try to move past them in order to preserve the friendship. It was impulsive on my part to cut him off without another word, and I did think of calling him myself after that. But I didn't. I stuck to that decision, one that I now greatly regret having made.
Fast forward to 2024, and I'm bringing the undelivered letter to J. inside. Without even opening it, I immediately put it through the shredder. I realize then that there is no way I'll ever know what happened to him. I had kept track of him in a sense online, as he'd sent me pictures of his children and of the new house he'd bought in Minnesota. He'd also gotten himself a dog, and he'd spoken often to me on the phone about how much the pup brightened his life. So after shredding the letter, I decided to do a little research and Googled his property. One real estate site reported that it had been sold in March 2022. That didn't set off any alarms at first, as I simply assumed he'd decided to sell and move elsewhere. I had no idea if he was even still in the Navy, as he was in his late 50's by that time. Again, I had no way of knowing anything, but I didn't dwell on it and put it away in the back of my mind.
Then, one evening about two weeks ago, the veritable tidal wave of his memory hit me. It was around 7 p.m., grey and cloudy as though it would rain, and I was sitting here at this computer. I checked the realty site again to make sure that I'd read correctly, and I had. I realized that now, there was no way I could ever know where he'd gone to. I didn't dare try calling him anymore, as I had no idea whatsoever of where his life and his relationship status stood. That left me no other recourse but to just give up.
His former mailing address had included a Post Office box number. His reason for doing that was that he didn't always get his mail due to the heavy snow they get in that area. So I decided to take a chance and send one last letter to him there. It was worth a shot, as he might still have been getting mail at the PO Box, or the post office might have forwarded the letter to him at his new address, wherever that was. It was worth trying. J. had always been worth it, and I was just only now realizing it.
For two weeks, I waited. Each time the phone rang, I hoped it was him, having decided to call me. I was ready for anything he'd have to say, good or bad. I just needed to hear his voice. But no. What calls I did get during those weeks were the usual from telemarketers and insurance companies, so I'd just delete them and keep hoping. Finally, at the end of those two weeks, when I'd almost stopped hoping, I opened the mailbox and there it was, the small envelope, bearing the familiar yellow label pasted over his PO Box number, informing me that the letter could not be delivered or forwarded. So that's it, I thought. He's moved and no longer gets his mail, so there is no way now that I'll ever know what happened him. Probably time to give up and console myself with the thought that I had, at least, tried.
When I got back inside, I shredded the letter unopened. Then, on an impulse that I didn't think would result in anything, I decided to try one more thing. I'd Googled his name often, but I'd never gotten anywhere with it. As unusual as his name is, there are plenty of other men with his exact name, with only their middle names being different. So I tried one more time in the hopes that it might link to a new address, a new town, a new place, something...anything...that might lead me back to him.
What I came up with was not at all what I'd expected. Of the top three links, the third showed his entire name, his date of birth, and...the date of his death. I grew numb with fear and thought...it can't be him. It must be another J. with the exact same middle name. But then I read the date of birth again, and I knew beyond a doubt that what I would read next would stop my world from turning. Once again, my intuition did not betray me. J. had indeed passed away in 2021, just a year after we'd last spoken, at the age of 59.
When I finally got the courage to open the link, there it was, his much younger face, smiling into the camera from beneath the Navy cap...the same deep dark eyes, the same tiny mustache, and the same playful little smile I'd seen so many times before. Then came the long list of survivors and those who had preceded his passing. I read it once, twice, and a few more times after that, trying to absorb the truth, and the final verdict: that I had at last found out what had happened to him and where he now was. The final confirmation was the photo of the pristine white headstone with his name and dates of birth and death, followed by the inscription: He now soars with the eagles.
So my search had ended, and not on the note I'd hoped for. The possibility that this is what I'd find had never entered my mind. But then, I thought back to the last phone conversation we'd ever had, some time back in 2020, which he had ended it in a way that he never had before, by saying "I love you, Rachel." I'd replied "I love you, too, J." That was the last time I was to ever his deep resonating voice, and it had left a strange feeling in me that he would say that to me in such a sincere way. Had he been trying to tell me something that day? Now I'll never know.
As I write this, I still haven't come to terms with the reality that now, I no longer have to wonder where he is and that I no longer have the chance to make things right with him. I'll never hear his voice again, never see his handsome face glowing in the light from a wood fire, never feel his arm wrap around me in bed. All of it is in the past now, and so is he.
I miss him, more than I can find the words to express here. I miss his vitality, his youthfulness, his sense of humor and adventure. I miss how we both loved many of the same things. I never forgot what he said to me once when we were in my bedroom. He was lying down watching me and I was at the window looking out over the woods he loved as much, if not more, than I did. "This place is where I belong," I said. "It's where I should have been all along." He replied, "You ARE this place, Rachel, and it is you."
Yes, I miss J. terribly. And if there is an afterlife, if there is a heaven or a wonderful place where there is no longer any weeping or suffering or sickness, and if one of the privileges of being there is that you can look down on those you left behind and he can see me standing here among them, then I pray that he looks kindly down on me and remembers, not only our good times together, but the fact that I loved him but never thought I had the right to say it. So I will now: I love you, J. I did then, I do now, and I always will. You touched my life in a way that no one has before or since, and you made so many of my dreams and wishes come true, more than you ever knew. Of all the people I've met whose memories have remained with me, your shines the most brightly.
So rest in peace, my old friend J. Soar with the eagles and bask in whatever reward God has blessed you with. And remember Rachel, your friend in Maine, who tried very hard to get you out of her heart but who never quite succeeded. 💖
The little fire pit where J. and I spent many wonderful evenings.